Giants Ridge Snowmaking Test: A Mundi Field Report

Giants Ridge Snowmaking Test: A Mundi Field Report

Illustrative commercial snowmaking scene; not a photograph of the 2009 Giants Ridge test.


At Giants Ridge Golf and Ski Resort in Biwabik, Minnesota, a December 2009 memorandum compares two snowmakers on the same water supply. One was fitted with Magnetizer® M-2 TRI (4120) units; the other was left untreated. The memo records supply pressure and snow-depth readings at two distances. The hero image is illustrative, not a photograph from the Giants Ridge test; the original field photographs appear below.

The account is useful because a third-party test supervisor documented the reported measurements and observations during a comparative field trial, rather than presenting them as Mundi performance claims.

01. The Giants Ridge test setup

The memorandum, dated December 23, 2009, describes two machines as identical and reports that they shared a water-supply line of the same diameter and length. The writer says that nozzles, filters, and positioning were matched, and that a resort employee witnessed the test.

Before installation, both machines were recorded at 305 PSI, with a stated variation of ±1 PSI. A measuring lath marked in three-inch increments was placed six inches into the snow bed at points 50 feet and 70 feet in front of the machines.

The report says the machines ran for roughly two to three hours before the writer returned at 3:15 p.m. to take measurements. It does not provide repeated runs or a detailed sampling map for the depth readings.

02. Pressure readings recorded in the memo

After the M-2 TRI units were installed on one snowmaker, the writer reports that its pressure rose to 328–330 PSI. The untreated machine remained at 305 PSI. The memorandum says pressure on the treated machine fell back to 305 PSI within about five minutes after the units were removed.

These are the memorandum’s reported gauge readings, not independently calibrated measurements. They describe the observed machines during this test and should not be taken as a general pressure response for other equipment.

03. Snow depth at 50 and 70 feet

The field report gives two depth comparisons. At 50 feet, it records 18+ inches for the machine with Magnetizer® and 12 inches for the untreated machine. At 70 feet, it records 18 inches with Magnetizer® and 10+ inches without it. The plus signs are retained as written in the source.

GIANTS RIDGE · DECEMBER 2009

Reported measurements

SNOW DEPTH · 50 FT

WITH M-2 TRI: 18+ in · CONTROL: 12 in

SNOW DEPTH · 70 FT

WITH M-2 TRI: 18 in · CONTROL: 10+ in

RUNNING WATER PRESSURE · AS RECORDED

WITH M-2 TRI: 328–330 PSI · CONTROL: 305 PSI

After removal, the treated machine returned to 305 PSI in approximately five minutes.

Original field photographs

SNOWMAKER COMPARISON

Original Giants Ridge snowmaking comparison photograph; snowmaker without Magnetizer®.

WITHOUT MAGNETIZER®

Original Giants Ridge snowmaking comparison photograph; snowmaker with Magnetizer® M-2 TRI.

WITH MAGNETIZER® M-2 TRI

DEPTH-LATH COMPARISON

Original measurement photograph supplied with the 2009 Giants Ridge memorandum; depth lath without Magnetizer®.

WITHOUT MAGNETIZER®

Original measurement photograph supplied with the 2009 Giants Ridge memorandum; depth lath with Magnetizer®.

WITH MAGNETIZER®

Historical, project-specific observations transcribed from the supplied memorandum. The readings were not independently verified; snow depth is not a direct measure of snow volume, mass, density, or water equivalent.

These are depth readings at two reported points, not measurements of total snow volume, mass, density, or water equivalent. The source does not describe enough sampling or collection data to calculate a facility-wide production increase from those readings.

04. Original field photographs

The supplied memorandum includes comparison photographs of the snowmakers and the measurement laths. Captions identify the machine condition shown; the source does not map each lath image to a specific 50-foot or 70-foot reading.

05. Operating conditions and the author’s conclusion

The writer reports a southwest wind of 4–6 mph and an air temperature of 27 degrees; the memorandum does not specify the temperature unit. The author describes the treated snow as softer and finer, and concludes that the units produced about 30% more snow with better quality. Those quality and percentage statements are the author’s interpretation, not independently measured outcomes.

06. What this past field test can—and cannot—show

The record is best read as a documented comparison that may inform further testing, with important limits:

  • It describes one test on one day with two machines; it does not report replicated or randomized trials.

  • Although the machines are described as identical and settings were reportedly matched, the memo does not document independent verification of those conditions or calibrated instrumentation.

  • Snow depth at two points does not establish total production, snow-water equivalent, density, or an independently measured change in snow quality.

  • The memo’s approximate 30% conclusion cannot be reproduced from the limited depth readings alone.

  • The reported observations are specific to this equipment, site, weather, water supply, and test procedure; they are not a performance guarantee.

For a current evaluation, a ski area would need an agreed protocol, matched operating conditions, verified pressure and flow measurements, repeatable snow sampling, and an independent way to compare output and quality. The 2009 memorandum offers historical context, not a substitute for that measurement.

07. Related Mundi resources

Industrial water applications →

Theory of Operation →

Tests & Evaluations →

Source memorandum

View the full source memorandum (PNG) →

LEARN MORE ABOUT MUNDI INDUSTRIAL WATER CONDITIONING

If you want to understand how magnetic conditioning compares to traditional softening — and why MundiMag™ focuses on honest, science-based performance — explore our product pages for real-world applications in industry.

↑ GO TO TOP